PicksToad&Co
Toad&Co: natural-fiber picks
Not scored. This is a list of individual products, not a FabricTruth score.
Outdoor-casual clothing. Most woven shirts we read are 100% organic cotton or hemp blends; knits, pants and fleece mostly blend in recycled polyester.
What else Toad&Co sells
Most of Toad&Co’s men’s woven shirts we read are 100% organic cotton, or hemp and organic cotton. The rest of the range leans on blends: many tees and hoodies mix recycled cotton with recycled polyester, the Mission Ridge chinos add polyester and elastane, and the fleece and Bitterroot pieces are almost all polyester.
- Re-Form knits: 60% recycled cotton, 40% recycled polyester
- Mission Ridge chinos and shorts: 21% recycled polyester plus elastane
- Fleece: the Cabinside Fleece Pullover is 100% recycled polyester
- Bitterroot waffle layers: 98% recycled polyester
- Hemp shirts like the Taj blend hemp with Tencel lyocell and a little elastane
- Insulated shirt jackets: the Pinevale Shirt Jacket has an all-cotton shell but recycled polyester insulation
Labels we read that are not 100% natural
| Product | Label | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Men’s Re-Form Crew Tee | 60% recycled cotton, 40% recycled polyester | Product page |
| Mission Ridge Straight Chino | 77% organic cotton, 21% recycled polyester, 2% elastane | Product page |
| Men’s Cabinside Fleece Pullover | 100% recycled polyester | Product page |
| Men’s Bitterroot Hoodie | 98% recycled polyester, 2% elastane | Product page |
| Pinevale Shirt Jacket | 100% organic cotton shell; 100 g/m² recycled polyester insulation | Product page |
How we checked
69 styles checked from 82 men’s styles in stock (colorways merged), on Oct 31, 2026. Every style, not a sample: we opened each product page and read the “Fabric” line. 69 of 82 had a composition we could read with confidence; 13 were missing one or were unclear (e.g. “100% recycled cotton and polyester”). Main fabric only; insulation and linings not counted. Not weighted by sales.
| Shell fabric | Styles | Share |
|---|---|---|
| 100% natural fiber shell | 20 | 29% |
| Natural + regenerated cellulose (modal, lyocell, viscose), no synthetics | 1 | 1% |
| Natural with 5% or less synthetic (usually elastane) | 13 | 19% |
| 6–49% synthetic | 25 | 36% |
| 50% or more synthetic | 10 | 14% |
This breakdown describes the styles we checked. It is not a score and does not rank Toad&Co against scored brands.
The picks
Pinevale Flannel Shirt
Shirts
Label 100% organic cotton
- Why it's here
- A plain all-cotton flannel.
- Watch out
- The insulated Pinevale Shirt Jacket shares the name but has polyester insulation.
- Lookalike to skip
- Pinevale Shirt Jacket: 100% organic cotton shell; recycled polyester insulation (source)
Product page · label read Oct 31, 2026 · price that day: $98
Creekwater Flannel Shirt
Shirts
Label 100% organic cotton
- Why it's here
- A printed cotton flannel.
- Watch out
- The organic claim is the brand’s; no certificate is shown on the page.
Product page · label read Oct 31, 2026 · price that day: $90
Men’s Scouter Corduroy Long Sleeve Shirt
Shirts
Label 100% organic cotton
- Why it's here
- All-cotton corduroy with no stretch fiber.
- Watch out
- Corduroy is heavier and slower to dry than a plain cotton shirt.
Product page · label read Oct 31, 2026 · price that day: $110
Rockland Long Sleeve Shirt
Shirts
Label 100% organic cotton
- Why it's here
- A heavier all-cotton work shirt.
- Watch out
- The most expensive of the Toad&Co shirts here.
Product page · label read Oct 31, 2026 · price that day: $130
Men’s Airscape Long Sleeve Shirt
Shirts
Label 100% organic cotton
- Why it's here
- A lightweight cotton shirt for warm days.
- Watch out
- Cotton holds more sweat than a polyester travel shirt and dries slower.
Product page · label read Oct 31, 2026 · price that day: $90
Men’s Arroyo Twill Shirt
Shirts
Label 100% organic cotton
- Why it's here
- An all-cotton twill shirt.
- Watch out
- Colors and sizes in stock vary.
Product page · label read Oct 31, 2026 · price that day: $90
Men’s Cascadia Cord Shirt
Shirts
Label 55% hemp, 45% organic cotton
- Why it's here
- Hemp and cotton, both natural.
- Watch out
- Not every Toad&Co hemp shirt is all natural: the Taj blends in lyocell and elastane.
- Lookalike to skip
- Men’s Taj Hemp Shirt: 54% hemp, 44% Tencel lyocell, 2% elastane (source)
Product page · label read Oct 31, 2026 · price that day: $98
Men’s Primo Short Sleeve Crew
Tees
Label 100% organic cotton
- Why it's here
- The least expensive all-cotton tee here.
- Watch out
- The Re-Form tees on the same site are 40% recycled polyester.
- Lookalike to skip
- Men’s Re-Form Crew Tee: 60% recycled cotton, 40% recycled polyester (source)
Product page · label read Oct 31, 2026 · price that day: $45
Men’s Primo Long Sleeve Henley
Tees
Label 100% organic cotton
- Why it's here
- An all-cotton long-sleeve henley.
- Watch out
- Vintage-wash colors vary from piece to piece.
Product page · label read Oct 31, 2026 · price that day: $60
Men’s Alpineglo Sweater
Knitwear
Label 50% merino wool, 50% organic cotton
- Why it's here
- A wool and cotton sweater in place of the brand’s polyester fleece.
- Watch out
- Half cotton. The blend comes from the page’s Fabric line; the title doesn’t mention it.
- Lookalike to skip
- Men’s Cabinside Fleece Pullover: 100% recycled polyester (source)
Product page · label read Oct 31, 2026 · price that day: $160
Canoe Henley Sweater
Knitwear
Label 70% organic cotton in conversion, 30% recycled cotton
- Why it's here
- All cotton, part of it recycled.
- Watch out
- “In conversion” means cotton grown on farms moving to organic that aren’t yet certified.
Product page · label read Oct 31, 2026 · price that day: $130
Sources
Links go straight to the brand; none are affiliate links. FabricTruth does not sell clothing. Labels are read from public product pages, not lab tests. Prices change; confirm on the brand site.